OCC lip tar on my eyes. NOT recommended, it contains peppermint oil which will irritate most eyes, but I have a tendency to break the rules on my own face. It gave an oil slicked look that actually didn't crease as noticeably, but again go with a clear gloss over a black base for safety & the same effect.
To minimize the focus of the "crease line", I used a mini fan brush (MUD #500) to feather out the edges & create further texture. A controlled mess if you will.
Stronger Feathering & tar test look
TEMPTU Pro Concealer Wheel Light
Graftobian HD Foundation Bombshell
Revlon Colorstay Powder Light
MAC Strada Blush (contour)
MAC Pink Swoon Blush
Laura Mercier Soft Blonde Brow Powder
Urban Decay Primer Potion
Michael Todd Longwear Cream Shadow City Love (base)
Illamasqua Medium Pencil Sophie
Physician's Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Mascara Duo
Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics Lip Tar Tarred (black glossed on lids)
MAC Angel Lipstick
MAC Cremesheen Glass Partial to Pink